PCC Collector Education

Authentication, explained.

Learn who authenticates sports memorabilia, how certification works, where to verify a number and what collectors should inspect before buying.

Why authentication matters

Authentication is an expert opinion about whether an autograph or collectible is genuine. A recognized certification, clear provenance and matching item details can strengthen buyer confidence, liquidity and long-term collectibility—but a valid database number should never replace inspection of the actual item, label and seller.

Featured source

Fanatics Authentic & UnderWraps

Fanatics says eligible authenticated memorabilia carries an individually numbered, tamper-evident hologram that can be checked through its online verification tool. UnderWraps is Fanatics’ officially licensed mystery-memorabilia program; product formats may include single-signed, inscribed, multi-signed, art, specialty and game-used chases depending on the release.

Featured source

MVPs

MVPs says it works directly with athletes to source exclusive signed memorabilia and that its items are verified and authenticated by Beckett. Beckett’s current system uses tamper-evident labels and digital certification records; some labels include QR access to the online record.

Featured source

ICONS.com & TripleLock™

ICONS says every signed item comes from controlled private signing sessions and includes an official Certificate of Authenticity with matching, uniquely coded holograms. Selected TripleLock™ items add an encrypted NFC tag, an individual signing photo and a secure digital record powered by Crane Authentication.

Official databases

Verify a certification

Fanatics / FanSecure

Locate the number printed at the bottom of the Fanatics hologram.

Open verifier ↗
Beckett Authentication

Enter the alphanumeric number without a space and compare the returned record.

Open verifier ↗
PSA / PSA-DNA

Use the number on the label, holder or DNA certification sticker.

Open verifier ↗
JSA

Enter the JSA certification number from the label, card or letter.

Open verifier ↗
ICONS.com

Tap the NFC tag on TripleLock™ items. For standard COAs, contact ICONS with the unique serial number.

Verification guide ↗

What certificates look like

Examples and details to inspect

Close-up of a Matty Beniers autograph with a Fanatics authentication hologram
Fanatics hologram on the itemLook for an intact, individually numbered hologram near the autograph or on the authenticated item. Enter that number only on the official Fanatics verifier and compare the returned details.
MVPs authentication information example
MVPs sourcing with Beckett authenticationMVPs establishes direct athlete relationships; its memorabilia is authenticated by Beckett. Inspect the Beckett label and confirm its number in Beckett’s official database.
ICONS TripleLock certificate, hologram and NFC authentication example
ICONS TripleLock™ systemSelected items combine an NFC tag, Certificate of Authenticity and matching tamper-proof hologram. The identifiers and item details should agree across every layer.

Examples are for education. Certificate and label designs can change over time. Never rely on appearance alone—use the company’s official verification method and compare the result with the exact item in hand.

Tamper-evident hologram or label

A numbered label is attached to the item or holder. Look for disturbance, residue, fragments, mismatched printing or placement inconsistent with the authenticator’s current format.

Digital certification record

The official database should return details that agree with the item: signer, item type and, when provided, an image or signing information. A database match alone does not prove that the item in hand is the same item.

COA or Letter of Authenticity

Documentation may carry the same serial number as the item label. Formats vary by authenticator and era; some companies now rely primarily on digital records rather than generic paper cards.

The PCC learning center

Guides we’re building next

This page is the foundation for a broader collector-education library.

  • Authentication vs. grading
  • Witnessed signatures vs. expert opinion
  • How to photograph memorabilia for resale
  • Understanding inscriptions and edition numbering
  • Game-used vs. player-worn memorabilia
  • How provenance affects value
  • Protecting jerseys, helmets, cards and photos
  • Buying authenticated memorabilia online